Understanding the Limitations of MoE Architecture in Ollama

Core Problem

The DeepSeek-R1 model, with its Mixture of Experts (MoE) architecture, is designed to reduce memory requirements during inference. However, users have reported issues when attempting to load the Q4 quantized model on systems with limited RAM.

Solution & Analysis

To understand why the MoE architecture does not provide sufficient system memory for the DeepSeek-R1 model, we need to examine the calculation of required system memory and how Ollama handles memory allocation.

# Total memory requirements for the full 671B parameters in Q4 quantization
full_memory_requirement = 325 GB

# Memory requirements for the active 37B subset in Q4 quantization with MoE
moe_active_subset_memory_requirement = 18.5 GB * 1.2 (overhead)

print(f"Full memory requirement: {full_memory_requirement} GB")
print(f"MoE active subset memory requirement: {moe_active_subset_memory_requirement} GB")

However, it appears that Ollama's current implementation does not accurately account for this memory overhead.

# Output from the error log
requested_memory = 446.3 GiB

# System available memory
system_available_memory = 37.3 GiB

print(f"Requested memory: {requested_memory} GiB")
print(f"System available memory: {system_available_memory} GiB")

if requested_memory > system_available_memory:
    print("Error: Model requires more system memory than is available.")

Conclusion

To overcome the limitations of MoE architecture in Ollama, users may need to rely on workarounds such as creating free swap or tricking Ollama into thinking that extra resources are available. Understanding the calculation of required system memory and how Ollama handles memory allocation can help developers optimize their models for efficient inference.

Reference

Source